Exista un moment foarte tare in “Logodnicii din America” al regizorului Nicolae Margineanu, cand personajul interpretat de Marcel Iures (un fost pilot casatorit cu o fosta stewardesa/securista) se duce la un fost securist, actualmente (fireste) om de afaceri, si-i urineaza pe birou… Scena (care apare pe la sfarsit) a fost adaugata de regizor, ea neexistand in scenariul initial scris de Eva Sirbu.
Filmul lui Margineanu ezita intre nuantele unui scenariu care vrea sa spuna o poveste “de viata” (si Securitate) cu o anumita eleganta (Eva Sirbu este un distins critic de film) si nevoia regizorului de a “pipera” povestea cu scene-soc. Faptul ca aceste doua viziuni nu s-au intalnit era previzibil; problema e ce facem cu ce a ramas…
Lucrurile bune sunt interpretarea retinuta a Tamarei Cretulescu (Maria, fosta prietena a securistei Sanda, pe care aceasta o turnase) si cea a lui Horatiu Malaele (partenerul de viata al Mariei, care e gay). Marcel Iures e OK, dar pare cumva subfolosit – nu are parte de Acea Scena care sa-l scoata in fata (cu exceptia celei de pipi). Maria Ploae face eforturi vizibile de a “demonstra” cu orice pret ca poate juca si un rol de scorpie alunecoasa, dar rezultatul e amestecat. Mai exista si “mama Eliza” (mama Mariei), care e Monica Ghiuta; n-am inteles de ce trebuie sa aiba cate-o palarie pe cap tot filmul, oricum nu o ajuta sa fie mai credibila (te astepti sa scoata in orice clipa o sticla de ulei de la “Bunica”)! Cei doi tineri, Oana Maria Margineanu (fiica Sandei) si Andrei Runcanu (fiul Mariei), sunt mai mult decorativi – pioni ai scenariului; fata Margineanu (in paranteza fie spus, regizorul si-a angajat toata familia: cealalta fiica, Ana, a fost regizor secund, fiul Petru a compus muzica, iar mama Maria joaca) are o scena care se vrea intensa (scoate pusca si trage la intamplare), dar e comica. Una peste alta, “Logodnicii din America” e o telenovela filmata pe malul lacului Snagov, sub un cer pe care trec avioane tot filmul (iar personajele simt nevoia sa le priveasca tot timpul!) si-n care “securisti” si “Securitate” sunt cuvinte mai frecvente decat “mama” si “tata”…
Alex Leo Serban
Critic de film
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_f1410c1d6a6b824dee352b8518912edc.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_a7243cca37802d6cd4c3e23ad944da76.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_4af4222442fe10e188cb8af4bfe72d25.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_d58fe1297aa93e77d8e2102a121fc909.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_3d56edd2b3001dd003aeb8363fc62534.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_0c491f402d1f3db96545a36adc3c1434.jpg)
:quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/276_17e2def220e58a66d916c9dc8e01a8b3.png)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/206_b7a51cbca205704e601850328c78a797.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/278_2dc662106ae0fd2996003075f7b5dc72.jpeg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/50_027bc5e0884cd5f20401d1f653addb72.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/281_a22b1443b905f56da42292528d1fd6ce.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/153_54a945b7bcc4a42d382684dd041848ec.webp)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/233_5cb06e43a186f695d1c40c1e289e4b5e.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/253_b9e8038ab590462aad9cccb69f0ebf08.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/197_b766093f9bc411b49cee1fc8f5e911af.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/284_c9f70687a9b3936c0917b6d98406c1a7.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/275_7f0b16ebab2b1809b31ac690110ef3c9.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/274_dbc387b46e93d47f6eb0d197c4238dfd.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/274_bddf343460099a541b2bbadcbd896d09.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/288_745d5002766da97c45b2f3399408edbb.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/16_26be3dc786006b2757866aeaca6e425b.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/289_8c1e0d84196caec6706fcb94810a203a.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/206_ec696ce6e1afb7eeb4241284aae8a01a.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/255_082288d6afe7b45890f976d0f3ac9623.webp)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/mu-plugins/rro-admin/assets/img/no-picture.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/204_c34be7f2948651005e925f46198f0cc2.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/204_0a3a2d473c1b3c3debcf54988c121712.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/bogdan-oprea0809-copy.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/aprindere-de-lumanari.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/287_8ce43bdb36ce696752bba1db10ab1739.jpeg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/287_4ca2a90a6843f260d687d82e63902556.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/codruta-filip-si-delia-desafio.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/justin-theroux.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/172_6248df911a5c642265b899d04e8fdb8d.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/172_cd6ce7149070819a8a9e80b076909123.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/179_3a65ef23db354ac092f7c2c1b42705e9.jpg)
:quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/179_246042b34857f66661de2bdd7c770f01.png)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/bogdan-ivan-scenarii-pret-carburanti-e1772954867337.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/hepta8777999.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/sofer-roman-de-tir-fericit-loc-de-munca-strainatate.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/laborator-cercetatori-stiinta.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/crucea-de-pe-varful-aneto-din-pirinei-scaled-e1776544469939.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/tara-europeana-testeaza-semafor-patru-culori.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/horoscop-19-aprilie-2026.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/avion-boom-sonic.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/ceai-de-dafin.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/pastele-blajinilor.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/concediu.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/tren-e1776582975648.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/sie.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/casatorii-fortate-marsul-impreuna-pentru-siguranta-femeilor-mars-id220104-inquam-photos-malina-norocea-copy.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/vaccin-copil.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/ilie-bolojan-george-simion-hepta8248545-scaled.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/cel-mai-bun-prieten-shutterstock684415648-copy.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/sorin-grindeanu-ilie-bolojan-shutterstock2672892819-copy.jpg)
Loghează-te în contul tău pentru a adăuga comentarii și a te alătura dialogului.