“Restul e tacere” – cel mai recent film al lui Nae Caranfil – este totodata si cel mai scump film romanesc de dupa 1989: 2.400.000 de euro. N-as fi adus in discutie aceasta cifra daca producatorul/distribuitorul nu ar fi scos-o in fata pentru a face publicitate filmului. Un fel de “Lume, lume, ia veniti aici sa vedeti cel mai scump film romanesc!” Va functiona asta, in termeni de incasari? Daca “4,3,2” a costat cam 600.000 de euro si a avut peste 70.000 de spectatori, ar trebui ca filmul lui Nae sa aiba de 4 ori
pe-atat. Pai nu?
Recunosc ca pe mine nu m-a convins. Ador “E pericoloso sporgersi”, imi place mult “Filantropica”, dar “Restul e tacere” (al carui scenariu dateaza de-acum 20 de ani!) mi se pare mai mult o marota a regizorului/scenarist si mai putin un film implinit. Povestea insasi e… datata: facerea primului lungmetraj romanesc, “Independenta Romaniei”, la 1912. Nae Caranfil ia filmul acela mai mult ca un pretext pentru a vorbi despre lupta dintotdeauna a unui artist cu finantele – de la banii necesari producerii lui la distributie s.a.m.d. Este o opera ambitioasa, plina de autoreferinte, care se intinde pe mai multi ani urmarind destinul celor implicati.
Filmul incepe cu o inmormantare si, pe la sfarsit, mai avem parte de una. O actrita moare arsa pe scena, un alt incendiu distruge pelicula; totul e teribil de trist. Povestea lui Grigore Ursache (Marius Florea Vizante), un tanar cu ceva bani si cu multe vise care se lanseaza in aventura “Primului film romanesc” nimerind pe mainile hraparete ale bogatasului Leon Negrescu (Ovidiu Niculescu), este presarata cu obisnuitele poante marca Nae C., dar cea mai tare “poanta” e ca nu prea-ti pasa de soarta personajelor… Actorii joaca gros, dar ni se spune ca “asa jucau ei”. Exista un moment emotionant cand Aristita, o fosta diva a teatrului (Ioana Bulca), ia in stapanire cadrul si-si recita lunga tirada in ploaie: daca “Restul e tacere” ar fi reusit sa pastreze acest ton pe tot parcursul filmului am fi avut, poate, o capodopera; asa, nu este decat un film bine “servit” tehnic, care “arata bine”, dar te cam plictiseste. Restul e publicitate.
Alex Leo Serban
Critic de film
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_e8d1a8e8482d6be7c880d89ad088cdd4.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_cba17ebece973c607b4a6c5d7326fefd.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_4af4222442fe10e188cb8af4bfe72d25.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_d26dd280db47f6c527ebb1812be88cdd.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_3437bc73621e88857a38953bd7b87e4f.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/280_0c491f402d1f3db96545a36adc3c1434.jpg)
:quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/276_9a422a4767982437d1460a2246984ed7.png)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/206_b7839103e33d841718ba419d1e7bd7be.jpeg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/278_2dc662106ae0fd2996003075f7b5dc72.jpeg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/50_027bc5e0884cd5f20401d1f653addb72.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/281_a22b1443b905f56da42292528d1fd6ce.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/153_3e6417414184ca71f7023a6872666571.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/233_5cb06e43a186f695d1c40c1e289e4b5e.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/253_8e4a2685e8d00186c3b07fd31dceac92.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/197_239d310aaadf51a5e23bd4f4a1bd328e.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/284_9a32a35bf37f718e820725f4f3ce1836.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/275_7f0b16ebab2b1809b31ac690110ef3c9.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/274_2b0b0d6a5c157124cf837250547e03ca.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/274_c570666b2217e7eaeaddaa8a4d7863b1.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/288_745d5002766da97c45b2f3399408edbb.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/16_80a09c649dd13e5229b1640f533a1d4c.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/289_44d867c5699b60885e9acc72bfea85aa.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/206_ffabc27a899d6c81bbfda1754bf5eb8c.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/255_082288d6afe7b45890f976d0f3ac9623.webp)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/mu-plugins/rro-admin/assets/img/no-picture.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/204_e80027ef4778596bbded749cfb1ebc99.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/204_0a3a2d473c1b3c3debcf54988c121712.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/barbat-consulta-acte.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/ilustratie-ploaie-inquam-photos-scaled-e1776403472321.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/287_8ce43bdb36ce696752bba1db10ab1739.jpeg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/287_4ca2a90a6843f260d687d82e63902556.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/madalin-ionescu-1.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/kaan-mirac-sezen.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/172_41bfa6e666e56fe072b6b3f223304899.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/172_cd6ce7149070819a8a9e80b076909123.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/179_3a65ef23db354ac092f7c2c1b42705e9.jpg)
:quality(75)/https://www.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/feed/images/179_246042b34857f66661de2bdd7c770f01.png)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/scandal-in-guvernul-bolojan--florin-barbu-si-alexandru-nazare-se-cearta-pe-motorina-ieftina-pentru-fermieri-si-proiectul-este-blocat--ce-risca-romania-document.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/ilie-bolojan.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/pasageri-llocuri-avion.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/portia-de-carte-17-aprilie2--foto-freepik-copy.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/durere.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/decese-suspecte-spital-sfantul-pantelimon.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/conflict-munca-shutterstock1209564136-copy-scaled-e1729282256127.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/izvorul-tamadurii.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/cum-alegi-paharul-pentru-bauturi.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/obiceiuri-care-iti-strica-parul-in-timp-ce-dormi.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/ceai-de-dafin.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/drona-tulcea-e1776401167402.webp)
:quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/viata-pacientilor-dependenti-de-dializa-este-pusa-in-pericol-prin-blocarea-unor-licitatii-suspecte--foto-geminigeneratedimage-scaled.png)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/avion.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/catuse-si-ciocan-judecator-e1773857995950.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/cel-mai-bun-prieten-shutterstock684415648-copy.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/sorin-grindeanu-ilie-bolojan-shutterstock2672892819-copy.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/donald-trump-presedinte-sua-10-4.jpg)
:contrast(8):quality(75)/https://static4.libertatea.ro/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/ilie-bolojan--foto-gov-ro.jpeg)
Loghează-te în contul tău pentru a adăuga comentarii și a te alătura dialogului.